Every day, millions of people post all sorts of comments, thoughts, and pictures on their social media profiles. Updating social sites has become so ingrained in our culture that it’s now considered a necessary part of our day-to-day routines.
Most of us assume friends and followers will read a message we’ve posted and understand it the way it was intended, but there’s no guarantee we won’t offend or irritate someone with an offhand status update. It’s impossible to know how anyone will react—and one small town realized that in the most horrific way…
Chelsie Cline, 25, was known as the fun-loving girl among her circle of friends in the small rural town of Melcroft, Pennsylvania. She was a young single mother who always had a positive attitude, and her enthusiasm for life was nothing short of contagious.
Chelsie had been dating a man named Tim Smith for several months. At first, their relationship was wonderful; Tim was attentive and loving. Soon, however, his constant attention became more smothering than anything else, and it was too much for Chelsie.
Eventually, Tim’s possessive behavior drove Chelsie away, and the two broke up. Not long after, Chelsie started spending time with a local man named Billy Porterfield, 27. Little did she know, her new relationship would place her front and center of a horrific tragedy…
Chelsie’s friends and family thought her ex-boyfriend was kindhearted, but they knew Tim had another side to him that was alarming: he loved drinking heavily and shooting guns. It was safe to say he had an infatuation with firearms…
In a town as small as Melcroft, nothing was a secret, and when Tim discovered Chelsie had started seeing someone else, he grew jealous of Chelsie and Billy’s new relationship. He didn’t make any attempt to hid his feelings.
Over the next few months, Tim stalked Chelsie. He left items on her car while she was at work. Once, he left beer and scratch-off lottery tickets; another time, it was a bouquet of flowers. He clearly wasn’t over their relationship, and it was slowly eating away at him.
Despite her usually sunny disposition, Chelsie couldn’t help but feel stressed. One evening, she posted a status on Facebook that read: “After this week, I really need to be taken out… on a date or by a sniper. Either one is fine with me at this point.” The post garnered one comment…
The first and only comment on Chelsie’s post was from none other than Tim, who wrote simply: “I could do both.” No one took this message as a threat, and life continued as usual until a few days later.
Four days after Tim’s strange Facebook comment, Chelsie; Billy; Chelsie’s half-brother, Seth; and their mutual friends Courtney and Sammi met at a local restaurant called Tall Cedars. However, when they arrived, Tim was also there—and he immediately started an altercation with Billy.
Words were exchanged between the two men, and they agreed to meet at a local car wash late that night to settle the dispute with their fists. Chelsie and Billy jumped in one car, and the other three followed behind in another vehicle. However, they had no idea of the horror that waited for them…
Chelsie and Billy arrived at the car wash around 3 a.m. They walked to the rear where they knew Tim was waiting. What they didn’t know, however, was he was also armed with three fully loaded guns and a ballistics vest. As they rounded the corner, he murdered the pair in cold blood; then he waited for the rest to arrive.
As soon as the other car pulled into the parking lot, Tim opened fire, shattering the windows and instantly killing both Seth and Courtney. He then turned the gun on himself and pulled the trigger.
The only survivor of the nightmare was Sammi, who crouched down in the back seat, terrified, during the chaos. Police arrived at the horrific bloodbath shortly after it ended and were shocked at what they found…
The residents of Melcroft were in disbelief at the events, too. The town lost four young adults who had bright futures ahead of them: Chelsie Cline, Seth Cline, Courtney Snyder, and Billy Porterfield (clockwise from top left).
Friends and family all consoled each other during the aftermath. After details of the incident emerged, everyone was left wondering why no one had taken Tim’s sinister Facebook response more seriously. If authorities were alerted, could they have prevented his deadly actions?
Vigils were quickly held for the victims, and people from all over Melcroft and the surrounding towns came to show their solidarity. It was an event that affected far too many innocent lives.
All around Melcroft were tributes to the victims. It seemed that everyone wanted to take part in paying their respects. The town knew it was going to be a while before any sort of normalcy returned.
Not only were there physical memorial sites built, but many friends of the victims’ families set up charities to raise money for their funeral expenses. None of the families were prepared to bury their children—nor should they have been.
One of the most heartbreaking details about the tragedy was that Chelsie and Courtney would never see their beautiful children grow into adults. Luckily, friends and family will tell the children how truly special their mothers were.
Tim Smith’s heinous actions resulted in an entire town mourning the loss of four beloved residents. It’s hard to say whether this tragedy could have been prevented if Tim’s Facebook comment was investigated, but it is a sobering reminder that serious threats should be taken seriously—even on social media.
This heartbreaking story is also a reminder that abusive behavior or harassment—especially from someone with a violent history or hobby—should not be ignored. Hopefully, the families of the victims can move forward with some sense of closure from these terrible events.
Share this important story with your friends below.