Throughout history, there have been plenty of unexplained mysteries that still baffle the world to this day. Even though experts have tirelessly researched and collected clues over the years, plenty of questions remain unanswered.

One of the most intriguing and truly bizarre cases involves a man named Peter Gibbs, a veteran pilot who decided to fly his plane one fateful night off the coast of Scotland. He didn’t return that evening—in fact, he was never seen again. What happened to him remains one of the world’s greatest unanswered mysteries…

Norman Peter Gibbs—who typically just went by the name “Peter”—was a 55-year-old businessman, gifted musician, and pilot from London, England. He’d developed a passion for flying planes during his days as an active pilot in World War II.

After serving in the war and a stint playing music professionally, Peter made a name for himself in property development. Yet, he still loved to fly his Cessna F150H when he wasn’t working on real estate deals.

On Christmas Eve in 1975, after working on an investment project in a hotel in Scotland, Peter decided to eat dinner at the Glenforsa Hotel (pictured) on the Isle of Mull. He had no idea what was in store for him that night.

The Isle of Mull was a small airfield where Peter had been keeping his Cessna aircraft in a hangar. Little did he know, this Christmas dinner would be the last meal he would ever enjoy again…

Despite the inclement weather conditions in the region caused by sleet, Peter decided to take his plane out for what he intended to be a quick, post-meal trip around the little island.

He was a stubborn man who never let anyone talk him out of an idea, and neither the hotel’s employees nor his girlfriend, Felicity, could convince him that the flight was an unwise decision.

Peter also refused to use any landing lights, and he completely ignored local regulations that banned flying at night. Instead, he asked Felicity to stand on the airstrip with a torch to guide himself back to the hangar.

He took off—and he never returned. Felicity spent the next 30 minutes waiting for Peter on the airstrip before finally returning to the hotel. Employees then called the police to report Peter missing.

Several hours later, on Christmas morning, a full-scale investigation was launched to find Peter’s body and plane. Helicopters and boats scoured the nearby waters, and hundreds of volunteers searched the island for signs. Nothing was found…

Then, in April of the following year, something utterly mind-boggling happened: Peter’s deceased body was discovered by a local shepherd near the Glenforsa Hotel. There was just one problem…

The hill where Peter’s body was found had already been thoroughly searched by authorities months earlier, and local shepherds and farmers worked in that area every single day!

It would have been impossible for them to completely overlook the body of a deceased man for four straight months. Plus, his body was in relatively good condition considering it was supposedly four months old.

What the heck was going on? Everyone who heard the news began to develop their own theories as to what could have happened to Peter. Still, these theories all left unanswered questions…

One theory supposed that the plane crashed at sea and that Peter swam to shore only to die of exposure shortly thereafter. However, there were no traces of seawater or marine microorganisms found on his skin or clothing.

Then there were others who suggested that Peter might have inexplicably jumped out of the plane, mid-flight. However, no parachute was ever recovered, making this idea also seem unlikely.

With few other details available, it must have seemed like Peter’s story was over. But then, in September of 1986, another startling discovery was made off the coast of Oban, a small town in Scotland…

Two brothers named Richard and John Grieve, both of whom were clam fishermen, stated that they found a small Cessna plane about a kilometer off the coast that matched the description of Peter’s vessel.

However, when salvage teams attempted to find what they were told may have been Peter’s old plane, it was gone. Had someone removed it? Had it been there in the first place? Yet again, Peter’s mysterious case hit a wall.

No one knew for sure what exactly happened to Peter Gibbs that stormy night, and perhaps nobody ever would. There were so many questions surrounding his death, and those mysteries would persist to this day…

Where had Peter’s body been hiding for the first four months before it finally appeared on the hill? And why was it in such good condition? As time went on, answers seemed less and less likely to emerge…

Where was Peter’s plane? Did the clam fishermen actually find it? These are the questions that will hopefully be answered one day, but until then, the world can only wonder about the great Mull Air Mystery.

Share this inexplicable mystery with your friends below!